First Erlangen Workshop on Cosmology and Quantum Gravity (2014)
First Erlangen Workshop on Cosmology and Quantum Gravity
Basic Information
Quantum gravity effects are expected to play a prominent role in the early universe as for example in the context of primordial gravitational waves or are expected to manifest in finger prints in the cosmic microwave background. After the expected publications of the new Planck data by the end of 2014 this workshop aims to bring together researchers from quantum gravity as well as from cosmology with links to current experiments, which are interesting also from the quantum gravity perspective.
The workshop will be held at the FAUErlangenNürnberg from 9th to 13th of February and participants will be experts equally distributed from both research areas. The workshop will be comprised of introductory talks of quantum gravity and cosmology with a particular focus on topics interesting for both communities as well as specialized talks and ample time for discussion, to stimulate interaction between the participants.
Invited Speakers
 Niayesh Afshordi (University of Waterloo)
 Ivan Agullo (Louisiana State University)
 Abhay Ashtekar (Pennsylvania State University)
 Tessa Baker (Oxford University)
 Camille Francois Bonvin (CERN)
 Latham Boyle (Perimeter Institute)
 Edmund Copeland (University of Nottingham)
 Raphael Flauger (Carnegie Mellon University)
 Ghazal Geshnizjani (University of Waterloo)
 Steffen Gielen (Imperial College London)
 JeanLuc Lehners (Albert Einstein Institute Golm)
 Lucas Lombriser (University of Edinburgh)
 Oriol Pujolas (IFAE and Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona)
 Tehseen Rug (LMU Munich)
 Angnis SchmidtMay (ETH)
 Edward WilsonEwing (Albert Einstein Institute Golm)
Local organizing Committee
 Kristina Giesel (University of ErlangenNürnberg)
 Stefan Hofmann (LMU Munich)
 Jochen Weller (LMU Munich)
The workshop is sponsored by the Emerging Field Project “Quantum Geometry” of the FAU ErlangenNürnberg and the Institute for Quantum Gravity.
Accomodation
Accommodation
All invited speakers of the workshop will be accommodated in the NH hotel in the city center of Erlangen.
NH Hotel Beethovenstraße 3 91052 Erlangen Tel: +49 (0) 9131 – 89120nherlangen@nhhotels.com Homepage NH hotel 
Arriving at the NH hotel from the train station
The NH hotel is located close the main train station and the city center in Erlangen. In case you arrive by train in Erlangen, you can just walk from the main station to the hotel. Exit the main train station from the main entrance, then walk straight for around 70 meters until you cross Hauptstraße. Turn right on this street and continue on for around 430 meters (Hauptstraße becomes Nürnberger Straße). After passing the high City Hall building, turn right onto Beethovenstraße. You will see the hotel on the lefthand side.
Conference Dinner
Conference Dinner
The conference dinner takes place on Wednesday night at 8 pm at the Restaurant Zen located in the city center.
Zen Bar & Restaurant Theaterplatz 22 91054 Erlangen Tel: +49 (0) 9131 – 9733166 Zen Bar & Restaurant 
The restaurant Zen is in walking distance from the hotel, about 1,5 kilometers. When leaving the NH hotel in the “Beethovenstraße” turn right onto the “Nürnberger Straße”. Follow the “Nürnberger Straße” until “Nürnberger Straße” intersects with the street “Henkestraße”. Cross this street and follow the pedestrian zone on the other side of the street, which is now called “Hauptstraße”. Stay on this street for about 1 km, the pedestrian zone ends on this part of the street. Keep going on for another 400m and turn right directly after the church on the MartinLutherPlatz (which is also the name of the bus station there – also bus 287). After 150m, at the end of the small place behind the church, you will find the ZEN restaurant on the lefthand side.
Program
Program
Program of the Workshop
All talks will be held in lecture hall F in the Physics Department.
Time  Monday  Tuesday  Wednesday  Thursday  Friday 

09:0010:15  Ghazal Geshnizjani  Kristina Giesel  Tehseen Rug  Lucas Lombriser  
10:1510:45  Coffee break  Coffee break  Coffee break  Coffee break  
10:4512:00  Ivan Agullo  Angnis SchmidtMay  Niayesh Afshordi  Steffen Gielen  
12:0013:30  Lunch break  Lunch break  Lunch break  Discussion until 13:00 

13:3014:45  Oriol Pujolas  Camille Bonvin  Tessa Baker  
14:4516:00  Edmund Copeland 15:00 until 16:15 
Raphael Flauger  JeanLuc Lehners  Edward WilsonEwing  
16:0016:30  Coffee break 16:1516:45 
Coffee break  Coffee break  Coffee break  
16:3017:45  Latham Boyle 16:4518:00 
Discussion  Discussion  Discussion  
17:4519:00  Abhay Ashtekar 18:0019:15 

19:15  Snacks & beer Foyer conference venue  
20:00  Conference Dinner Zen Erlangen 
Titles and Abstracts
Sepaker: Edmund Copeland
Title: Inflation in light of Planck
Abstract: I will discuss the Inflationary Universe scenario and the way recent Planck measurements have impacted on favoured models of inflation. I will then go on to briefly discuss the place of inflation in a number of approaches to Quantum Gravity, pointing out successes and problems as I see them. Hopefully this will lead to the start of a discussion in this interesting workshop concerning the cosmology associated with Quantum Gravity.
Speaker: Latham Boyle
Title: Rethinking Connes’ Approach to the Standard Model of Particle Physics via NonCommutative Geometry
Abstract: Connes’ notion of noncommutative geometry (NCG) generalizes Riemannian geometry and yields a striking reinterpretation of the standard model of particle physics, coupled to Einstein gravity. I will start with a gentle introduction to his approach and the physical reasons to be interested in it. I then explain our recent reformulation, which has two key mathematical advantages: (i) it unifies many of the traditional NCG axioms into a single one; and (ii) it immediately generalizes from noncommutative to nonassociative geometry. Strikingly, it also resolves a longstanding problem plaguing the NCG construction of the standard model, by precisely eliminating from the Lagrangian the collection of 7 problematic terms that previously had to be removed by an ad hoc assumption. Applying this new formulation to the NCG traditionally used to describe the standard model, we find that, instead, it actually describes a certain minimal extension of the standard model by an extra U(1)_{BL} gauge symmetry, and a single extra complex scalar field sigma, which is a singlet under SU(3)_{C} x SU(2)_{L} x U(1)_{Y} but carries baryonminuslepton charge BL=2. This extension has phenomenological and cosmological implications, and offers a new solution to the discrepancy between the observed Higgs mass of 125 GeV and the traditional NCG prediction of 170 GeV.
Based on: 1) Latham Boyle and Shane Farnsworth, “Noncommutative geometry, nonassociative geometry and the standard model of particle physics,” New J. Phys. 16, 123027 (2014) [arXiv:1401.5083]. 2) Shane Farnsworth and Latham Boyle, “Rethinking Connes’ approach to the standard model of particle physics via noncommutative geometry,” New J. Phys. 17, 023021 (2015) [arXiv:1408.5367].
Speaker: Abhay Ashtekar
Title: Preinflationary dynamics in LQC: Interplay between theory and Observations
Abstract: In Loop Quantum Cosmology (LQC) the bigbang singularity of the FriedmanLemaitre models is naturally resolved because of quantum geometry effects. Furthermore, one can systematically extend the cosmological perturbation theory from classical to quantum background geometries. This enables one to analyze the preinflationary dynamics in detail by facing the Planck regime squarely. Contrary to a widespread belief, this phase of dynamics can have observational consequences. In particular, it can lead to quantum states that differ from the Bunch Davies vacuum at the onset of inflation, with interesting consequences for the observable properties of the longest wave length (or low $\ell$) modes. I will discuss these and the resulting interplay between observations and the question of initial conditions in quantum gravity. This talk will also provide the background material for many more the phenomenological consequences of LQC that Ivan Agullo will discuss.
The results I will present were obtained jointly with Ivan Agullo, Alex Corichi, Brajesh Gupt, William Nelson, Tomasz Pawlowski and Param Singh. This work was supported in part by the NSF grant PHY1205388 and the Eberly research funds of Penn State.
Speaker: Ghazal Geshnizjani
Title: Theoretical implications of detecting gravitational waves
Abstract: I will discuss in what sense detecting primordial gravitational waves is a smoking gun for inflation. I argue that a detectable tensor signal on large scales and sourced by vacuum fluctuations in a nonaccelerating, subPlanckian universe using cosmological perturbation theory leads to contradictory limits on cosmological dynamics. The contradiction implies that one or more of our axioms for early universe must have been broken. The bound from tensor perturbations will not only independent of, but also stronger than the one obtained from scalar power spectrum.
Speaker: Ivan Agullo
Title: Phenomenological consequences of LQC
Abstract: Loop quantum cosmology has become a robust framework to describe the highest curvature regime of the early universe. This talk will describe explore the phenomenology of this framework. We will discuss the parameter space of the theory, both for the background spacetime geometry and for metric perturbations. We will then explore the corrections to the inflationary predictions for the primordial spectrum of cosmological perturbations that the preinflationary, quantum gravity phase of the universe introduces. NonGaussianity and its relation to large scale anomalies in the CMB will be discussed.
Speaker: Oriol Pujolas
Title: Status of NonRelativistic Quantum Gravity
Abstract: I will give my personal view on the present status of Horava’s proposal for Quantum Gravity. The lowenergy limit of the theory is rather well behaved but it requires new ingredients in order to overcome the most serious lowenergy issue — the Lorentz fine tuning problem or why the matter sector is Lorentz invariant to such a great precision. I will present the recent progress made in this direction. I will also review other aspects, including Black Hole physics and cosmology.
Speaker: Raphael Flauger
Title: Planck, BICEP, and the Early Universe”
Abstract: The cosmic microwave background contains a wealth of information about cosmology as well as high energy physics. It tells us about the composition and geometry of the universe, the properties of neutrinos, dark matter, and even about the conditions in our universe long before the cosmic microwave background was emitted. After a brief review of what we may hope to learn from studies of the cosmic microwave background about the early universe, I will review measurements of the angular power spectrum of temperature perturbations from the first 15.5 months of Planck data by the Planck collaboration and by Renee Hlozek, David Spergel and myself. I will then discuss the implications for the early universe of the recently released Planck full mission data as well as the joint analysis between BICEP/KeckArray and Planck.
Speaker: Kristina Giesel
Title: Loop Quantum Gravity as a Motivation for Manifestly Gauge Invariant Perturbation Theory
Abstract: The underlying theoretical framework of loop quantum cosmology is loop quantum gravity, which will be briefly introduced in this talk with a particular focus on the assumptions and choices one makes when passing from general relativity to its corresponding quantum theory. It will be discussed how a reduced phase space approach to loop quantum gravity can be used to formulate a manifestly gauge invariant version of general relativistic perturbation theory. The latter allows to disentangle the construction of gauge invariant quantities (observables) from the perturbation theory. The application of this approach to cosmological perturbation theory is analysed and compared to the results one obtains in standard cosmological perturbation theory.
Speaker: Angnis SchmidtMay
Title: Consistent Spin2 Field Theories
Abstract: Cosmological and astrophysical observations suggest the presence of dark energy and dark matter, indicating that known physics may not suffice to completely describe our universe. There are many different possibilities to go beyond the standard models of particle physics and gravity in order to remedy deficiencies of the currently known descriptions. In this talk, I will introduce models that involve massless and massive spin2 fields instead of only a massless graviton. The only theories of this type which avoid an unacceptable ghost instability are ghostfree nonlinear massive gravity and its generalization to bimetric theory. Ghostfree bimetric theory possesses selfaccelerating cosmological solutions and can reproduce the expansion history of the universe. Around such solutions, the linear perturbation theory can also be in accordance with observational data. Its interesting mathematical structure and its viable cosmology make bimetric theory a promising alternative to general relativity.
Speaker: Camille Bonvin
Title: Relativistic effects in largescale structure
Abstract: A key challenge in cosmology is to understand the current accelerated expansion of the universe. The distribution of galaxies, as well as their observed shape and size provide a powerful way to probe dark energy and modified gravity models. In order to exploit these observables properly it is necessary to understand what we are really measuring when we look at the distribution, sizes and shapes of galaxies. Since our universe is not completely homogeneous and isotropic, we only see a distorted picture of our sky. In this talk, I will discuss the various relativistic effects that distort our observations. I will show that even though these effects complicate the interpretation of galaxy surveys, they are very useful since they contain information on the dynamic of the universe and can therefore be regarded as a new opportunity for future surveys.
Speaker: JeanLuc Lehners
Title: Inflationary and ekpyrotic universes in the noboundary wavefunction
Abstract: I will review the noboundary proposal, paying particular emphasis on the conditions for obtaining a classical spacetime in the noboundary wavefunction. This analysis singles out inflationary and ekpyrotic cosmologies, and so I will discuss the implications for both types of cosmologies. The talk will also include a discussion of the current observational status of these two theories, and of open issues that remain to be understood.
Speaker: Tehseen Rug
Title: Quantum Bound States – From QCD to Gravity
Abstract: After reviewing some basics of gravity and QFT in curved spacetime, I will explain how to approach gravity from a field theorists perspective. I will try to motivate that it is natural to consider large gravitating sources, such as planets or black holes, as bound states of microscopic degrees of freedom such as gravitons. After discussing some qualitative, kinematic aspects of this picture and its implications, I will introduce a theoretical framework that allows one to deal with these gravitational bound states. This formalism is very close to that used in other field theories such as QCD. Using this framework, I will present results for observables such as number density and energy density inside gravitational bound states in pure gravity. I will explain how these observables can be extracted by an outside observer doing scattering experiments. I will conclude with a summary and an outlook.
Speaker: Niayesh Afshordi
Title: The Cosmological NonConstant Problem: the case for TeV scale quantum gravity
Abstract: We study the influence of the fluctuations of a Lorentz invariant and conserved vacuum on cosmological metric perturbations, and show that they generically blow up in the IR. We compute this effect using, i) a toy model of Poisson sprinkling in the phase space, ii) KallenLehmann spectral representation of stress correlators, and iii) holographic bound on entanglement entropy, all leading to an IR cutoff that scales as the fifth power of the UV scale (in Planck units). The leading effect comes from anisotropic vacuum stresses; consistency with cosmological observations limits the highest UV scale of the quantum field theory to be < 20 TeV 2 PeV, which is also independently motivated by the Higgs hierarchy problem, and one may interpret as the scale of quantum gravity. Our findings can be viewed as an extension of the cosmological constant (CC) problem which demonstrates the nontrivial UVIR coupling and (yet another) failure of effective field theory in gravity. However, it is more severe than the old CC problem, as vacuum fluctuations cannot be tuned to cancel, due to the positivity of the covariance of the stress tensor.
Speaker: Tessa Baker
Title: Testing Gravity with Cosmology
Abstract: I’ll begin by giving an overview of the space of gravity theories currently under consideration by the cosmology community, constructed as candidate explanations for the accelerating expansion rate of the universe. I’ll talk briefly about sensible strategies for testing these theories. I’ll then move to the main focus of this talk, which is the construction of a unified parameter space for tests of General Relativity. This seeks to draw together, in an intuitive way, constraints from laboratory, astrophysical and cosmological systems. I’ll point out some interesting observations that emerge from the construction of this parameter space, including an untested regime of gravitational fields which deserves further investigation.
Speaker: Edward WilsonEwing
Title: A ΛCDM Bounce Scenario
Abstract: We study a contracting universe composed of cold dark matter and radiation, and with a positive cosmological constant. Assuming that loop quantum cosmology captures the correct highcurvature dynamics of the spacetime, we calculate the spectrum of scalar and tensor perturbations after the bounce, assuming initial quantum vacuum fluctuations. We find that the modes that exit the (sound) Hubble radius during matterdomination when the effective equation of state is slightly negative due to the cosmological constant will be nearly scaleinvariant with a slight red tilt, in agreement with observations. The tensor perturbations are also nearly scaleinvariant, and the predicted tensortoscalar ratio is small.
Speaker: Lucas Lombriser
Title: Observational signatures of screening mechanisms in scalartensor gravity
Abstract: Scalar fields can serve as alternative to a cosmological constant driving cosmic acceleration, plausibly representing the effective lowenergy limit of a more fundamental theory of gravity. In case of nonminimal coupling, the new field modifies the gravitational interactions. These modifications must, however, be suppressed in the Solar System, where gravity is well tested. Hence, viable scalartensor theories employ screening mechanisms to satisfy the local constraints, but they leave observable signatures on cosmological and galactic scales. I will discuss some of these effects and constraints that can be inferred from them. Finally, I will present a new, linear shielding mechanism, where gravitational modifications may be limited to scales near the cosmological horizon.
Speaker: Steffen Gielen
Title: A homogeneous universe as a quantum gravity condensate
Abstract: Quantum gravity provides the opportunity to answer questions of modern cosmology while avoiding some of the theoretical issues of inflation. The challenge then is to describe a cosmologically relevant, i.e. timedependent and nearly (but not quite) homogeneous, universe within a given approach to quantum gravity, in order to extract cosmological predictions. I will outline a new approach addressing this challenge in the group field theory (GFT) approach to quantum gravity, closely related to loop quantum gravity (LQG). In our approach, a homogeneous universe is described, in a first approximation, as a `gas’ of weakly interacting discrete building blocks (`atoms’) of space. The gas is characterised by an order parameter describing the collective state of many coherent degrees of freedom, and mathematically similar to a BoseEinstein condensate in condensed matter physics. Continuum spacetime, together with a spatially homogeneous metric, arises as an approximate hydrodynamic description of a particular phase (given by this `condensate’) of a fundamentally discrete quantum gravity theory. I will present the analogy between these GFT `condensates’ and real condensates in some detail. The analogue in GFT of the GrossPitaevskii equation governing the dynamics of a real condensate is interpreted as an effective quantum cosmology model from which possible phenomenology can be extracted. I will then outline several further possibilities for the phenomenology of GFT condensates, including the description of inhomogeneities, a possible transition between `geometric’ and `nongeometric’ phases in the very early universe, and potential unexpected consequences for issues such as the cosmological constant problem.
Travel Details
Workshop Venue
The workshop takes place at the Department of Physics, University of ErlangenNünberg, Staudstr. 7, 91058 Erlangen. The Physics Department is located on the South Campus and can be reached from Erlangen city center by bus. The closest bus station to your hotel, which has a direct bus connection to the Physics Department is “Erlangen Arcaden”.
At the bus stop directly in front of the shopping mall at the “Güterhallenstraße”.